World Press Photo Gallery

As a sponsor of the World Press Photo 07 exhibition in Toronto, The Walrus is pleased to present a critical analysis of a selection of the images.
As a sponsor of the World Press Photo 07 exhibition in Toronto, The Walrus is pleased to present a critical analysis of a selection of the images.

Photographer: Oded Balilty, Israel, The Associated Press

Description: A Jewish settler resists Israeli riot police enforcing a Supreme Court order to demolish nine homes in an outpost of the Amona settlement, West Bank. Residents joined by thousands of other protesters raised barbed wire barriers to protect the houses and clashed violently with police. Over 200 people were injured, including 80 policemen. Following hours of confrontation, the settlers were dragged away and bulldozers moved in to begin the demolition.

Comment by Ken Alexander, editor of The Walrus:
“I am not at home when I am at work, and not at work when I am at home,” said Karl Marx, describing alienated labour. But what if your home is your work, your religion, and your ideology, and your own state, the one you believe in, has come to take it away from you, or you away from it? This is the dilemma captured in and through this brilliantly simple and evocative image. The fact that it appears staged — a lone woman settler pushing up against the muscle of the Israeli military — lends an almost endearing quality to it: the human spirit working against a machine that has become unknown, so unknown that it doesn’t think twice about this strange removal. Like much great war imagery, this photograph is confusing, as confusing as the human agency that leads to the extinguishment of ideas and causes.
Further reading in The Walrus:
- "A House Divided" by Jonathan Garfinkel (March 2007)

Add a comment

  
I agree to walrusmagazine.com’s comments policy.

Canada & its place in the world. Published by
the non-profit charitable Walrus Foundation
TwitterFacebookRSS
On newsstands now
New Issue on Sale
June 2012
Subscribe online for as little as $2.49 an issue. Visit The Walrus Store
to buy prints of our covers
The Walrus Foundation National Event Guide

The Walrus HOOPP Pension Debate
Be It Resolved That Canadians Are Incapable
of Saving for Their Retirement Needs Alone

12 pm, Wednesday, May 30 at
Hart House Debate Room, Toronto

The Walrus Glenbow Debate
Calgary’s Cowboy Culture:
Living Legacy or Just History?

6:30 pm, Thursday, June 7 at
Epcor Centre: Max Bell Theatre, Calgary

The Walrus Laughs
The Walrus SoapBox