Kingdom Come

Can Halifax’s Shambhala Buddhist community keep the faith?
In Tibetan Buddhist lore, the Kingdom of Shambhala is an enlightened society of citizens governed by compassion rather than religious doctrine. It’s usually seen as a spiritual metaphor, but in 1976 Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche, flamboyant guru to the likes of Allen Ginsberg, announced to his American followers that he had discovered its earthly location. “He said, ‘We’re all moving to Nova Scotia,’ ” says Jeremy Hayward, a senior Buddhist teacher. “We thought it was some kind of joke.”

Such a joke would not have been out of character: the famously charismatic Trungpa offered a freewheeling spiritual guidance heavy on sensual pleasure. Born to Tibetan nomads in 1940, he was identified as a tulku (reincarnation of a great religious leader) at the age of one and raised in a monastery, where he remained until fleeing the Chinese invasion in 1959. Soon afterward, he departed his refugee camp for Oxford, leaving behind a son, Ösel Mukpo. There, Trungpa took to Western diversions, especially drink, and in 1969 he blacked out behind the wheel of a sports car and drove into a joke shop. He was left partially paralyzed.

Taking the karmic hint, he renounced his monastic vows to become a lay teacher, and headed across the ocean to Boulder, Colorado, with a sixteen-year-old bride in tow. American students flocked to him there for more than a decade. But Trungpa was seeking a kind of spiritual terroir, and feeling that the beautiful mountain scenery bred complacency, he cast around for a place where enlightenment would come by way of struggle. In search of fickle weather and rugged terrain, he found Halifax.

A star is born, and born, and born Past-life regression therapy as a cure for anonymity Illustration by Patrick KylePatrick KyleDr. Adrian Finkelstein, a “classically trained physician” and “board-certified psychiatrist,” is one of the world’s foremost practitioners of past-life regression therapy. While he’s practised for thirty years, his big break came when he discovered that one of his patients, the Canadian pop singer Sherrie Lea Laird, was the reincarnation of Marilyn Monroe. The ensuing book, Marilyn Monroe Returns: The Healing of a Soul (2006), substantiates his find with “scientific” evidence — but more important, it serves as the Marilyn tell-all that never was, “revealing for the first time the inner thoughts and feelings of the world’s most famous sex symbol.” Finkelstein — who seems to keep illustrious company — is, for his part, the reincarnation of MGM executive Paul Bern. He learned this from another patient, the reincarnation of Bern’s widow, Jean Harlow. — Mira Saraf
His followers, mostly typical American yuppies, set up camp in what was then a Keith’s-swilling port town more fog covered than forward thinking. “It was pretty dismal,” says Michael Chender, a long-time student. “When I moved, they were just beginning to import sun-dried tomatoes.” To make matters worse, Trungpa, suffering from a host of complications from heavy drinking, died soon after his arrival. Hundreds of Buddhists assembled under his appointed successor, Ösel Tendzin (born Thomas Rich in New Jersey), but his reign did not last long: he openly slept with his followers, and when it came to light that he had knowingly infected one of his male students with HIV (having falsely assumed that enlightenment was the best protection), he escaped to California, where he died of AIDS-related causes. That left some 800 Buddhists marooned in the Canadian Maritimes — bereft, expatriated, and sans guru.

“It was a long, difficult period,” recalls Hayward. “It was very uncertain what would happen with Shambhala.” But even though members of the community remember these as lost years, suffering eventually begat growth, just as Trungpa had predicted: in the absence of strong religious leadership, the Buddhists’ influence in their adopted home took root. Highly educated and largely well off, they brought a much-needed influx of cultural capital to Halifax. They opened coffee shops, bookstores, and imported food markets; they founded the Shambhala School in 1993, now the preferred choice for alternative education among Buddhists and non-Buddhists alike (Ellen Page is a graduate), as well as the renowned Authentic Leadership in Action Institute. And they became civic leaders, forming the backbone of an environmental movement. Thanks to them, Halifax grew from a town-going-on-city into a centre of granola culture — not far off the mark from the Kingdom of Shambhala Trungpa had envisioned.

Then, in 1995, things changed: Trungpa’s son returned. Mukpo, now a man of thirty-three with delicate, fine-boned features, had followed his father to America in 1972 but struggled with Western life. He had been studying in Nepal when Tendzin died, and returned to North America only at the urging of his father’s former teachers, Tibetan spiritual aristocrats. Upon arrival, he largely avoided Halifax, spending several years visiting Buddhist centres across the continent.

When he finally showed up in Nova Scotia to lead his father’s kingdom, taking on the mantle of the Sakyong, or “Earth protector,” he was conveniently identified — by the same Tibetan higher-ups who had sent him back to North America — as the reincarnation of Mipham the Great, a Buddhist teacher who had not claimed an earthly body since 1912. The discovery gave credence to his spiritual mettle, but the Sakyong was certainly a late-blooming tulku. “I think all along he knew he was his father’s son,” says Hayward. “The discovery of the Mipham connection gave him that seat publicly. It was as if he’d been hiding his light, and he didn’t need to hide it anymore.”

But not everyone saw the light. “The Sakyong is driven by personal insecurity,” says Mark Szpakowski, one of the creators of Radio Free Shambhala, an online forum for discontented Buddhists. “He has really big shoes to fill — impossible shoes to fill, actually.” Even stalwarts admit that he lacks his father’s magnetism: “He was very, very shy,” recalls Hayward, who served as his tutor in Boulder. “I did feel that he was pure, but I wasn’t sure if he really had the power of his father.” Doubts gave way to outright disapproval among a small but vocal group when the Sakyong, faced with a staggering inheritance from his larger-than-life father, amalgamated the spiritual and secular components of Trungpa’s empire, formally creating Shambhala Buddhism in 2000. Trungpa loyalists assert that the merger has polluted both streams, recasting the community in religious terms and insulating it against the city it was meant to be rooted in. Old-line Buddhism has closed the gates to the compassionate kingdom.

Lacking his father’s natural flair, the Sakyong has appealed to tradition — spiritual destiny — to bolster his leadership. Trungpa was a pot-bellied man who wore a grey suit and an impish grin; that his students affectionately called him Rimp the Gimp speaks to his playful charm. The Sakyong, swaddled in traditional Tibetan robes when he appears in public, speaks with the humourless affect of one who has taken pains to overcome timidity. In 2006, he was married, with great pomp and circumstance, to the aristocratic daughter of another high Tibetan lama, and in August the royal couple gave birth to their first child. “It’s almost certain that the Sakyong’s children are going to be great tulkus,” Hayward enthuses. “They’re not just going to be any old people.”

The Buddhist brass has gone to great, ceremonial lengths to turn the Sakyong’s Eastern authenticity into a cult persona — but in the end, you can’t fake charisma. “Trungpa Rinpoche was a genius. He was a culture creator,” says Michael Chender. “What a hell of a situation for his son to be in. The Sakyong is a human being.”

6 comment(s)

Michael ChenderNovember 08, 2010 16:22 EST

While it is true that Trungpa Rinpoche felt that moving from the comfort-obsessed US to the more elemental environments of Nova Scotia would help his students become more authentic, it is not the primary reason he chose to come here. Rather, he felt that the encounter between the sanity, earthiness, and kindness evident throughout this province, and the appreciation of mindfulness, compassion and sacredness of the ordinary in the Buddhist and Shambhala traditions would, perhaps over generations, inform a society that could be a model to the world. In this difficult time, many of us here, and by no means just Buddhists, feel that this is a vision well worth pursuing.

Miles ParkerNovember 09, 2010 22:52 EST

My parents were part of the original Boulder community and my mother and I have been part of the Shambhala community ever since. While I was less around ten at the time, and saw him only a few times, I feel an incredible sense of gratitude and love for Trungpa Rinpoche. It may sound sentimental, but it really does feel as if he is still here. There are very few people who were ever around him that don't feel that way. Trungpa Rinpoche was not some drinking, partying, wild and crazy guy or at least not in the way that comes across in so many press accounts. He was a genuine enlightened being who choose to manifest — meet the world — in certain ways, reflecting and liberating everyone and everything around him. When your motivation is to liberate others and you put that beyond everything else, that means making people uncomfortable, because it is our retreat into comfort that prevents us from actually seeing the world for what it is and from recognizing what the world really needs. The line of teachers in our particular branch of Buddhism are all like that — many of their activities make Trungpa Rinpoche look quite mild. Perhaps this approach is not for everyone, but it works.

Over and over on the path — any spiritual path — we think we've understood the point, and then realize we've completely missed it. For example, we think, "the teacher is acting crazy in order to shock us out of our conventional minds". But that isn't really the point. The point is that the teacher is acting in whatever way the situation requires. Like Trungpa Rinpoche, The Sakyong manifests in ways that may or may not be comfortable for people. They don't like his demeanor, or they don't like how he organizes things, or they don't like what he wears. Mostly, they aren't getting what they expect to get from him. From what little I know, that's a pretty good signal that the teacher is offering exactly what is needed.

I have great respect for The Sakyong Mipham Rinpoche, and a commitment to the vision of Shambhala, but he is not my main teacher. (I've got to say though, people who who say that he is "humorless" or "timid" must have never *really* met him.) I have a really hard time with much of the Halifax "old-dog" scene, and — though it is such a sweet thing, really — trappings like the "Royal Nursery" make me cringe and wonder if we aren't in danger of confusing the props for reality. But it is up to me to decide how to relate to all of that and work with it on my own path. I would suggest as gently as I can that those who have been labeled "disaffected" Shambhala Buddhists carry the same responsibility. And that all of those who remain "affected" we need to remind ourselves that this is all a great display and it is our teachers that have kindly created it for us.

From the eyes of a ten year old, the Shambhala Community of the 1970s was not particularly kind or accommodating, but my guess is that without the sharpness it had then, we would not have what we have now. The Shambhala Community of the late 80s was awful, to an almost exquisite degree. The vibe and story-line kept me away for a very long time. But the Shambhala Community I re-encountered in the late 90s was welcoming and accommodating. And the Shambhala Community of 2010 is infinitely kinder, more generous and more firmly planted then it was thirty years ago. The Sakyong gave us that.

Finally, I wanted to say something that at the moment seems more important to me than anything else, that actually brings me to tears. What Canada has given to the Shambhala Community is far more precious and necessary then what the Shambhala Community has given and will give to Canada. As an aspiring immigrant please let me offer my admiration and gratitude to "The True North strong and free!"

Andrew SaferNovember 10, 2010 14:43 EST

This article covers a lot of ground, but not deftly.

Some of the points raised here are shallow, and show a lack of grasp of the subject matter...

"Thanks to them (the Buddhists in Halifax), Halifax grew from a town-going-on-city into a centre of granola culture — not far off the mark from the Kingdom of Shambhala Trungpa had envisioned."

Doe the writer actually believe there is a connection between "centre of granola culture" and "the Kingdom of Shambhala Trungpa had envisioned"? If so, one wonders about the depth of her research. More likely, it's an offhand comment meant to inject a bit of levity into the piece—but it doesn't work because it trivializes the subject.

The quotes attributed to Chender and Szpakowski, I'm sure, do not do justice to what they said in their interviews. This is sound-bite journalism, all about flashing a colourful sentence rather than attempting to convey the depth and nuances of what was being expressed. The former is much easier, but what does it accomplish?

Christine KeyserNovember 10, 2010 17:52 EST

The writer of this article, Suzannah Showler, is the daughter of former Shambhala sangha members. In the interest of unbiased reporting, the editors should have revealed that in the article.

Suzanne DuarteNovember 11, 2010 12:08 EST

Ummm. I would like to point out that all of Trungpa Rinpoche's teachers were dead by 1992. Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche, the last remaining elder teacher of Trungpa Rinpoche, may have urged Osel Mukpo to return to North America before he passed on in November 1991, but none of Trungpa Rinpoche's teachers identified Osel Mukpo as Mipham the Great or empowered him as Sakyong. The "higher up" lama who did that was Penor Rinpoche, who had no connection with Trungpa Rinpoche. That's a whole different story. Just for the record.

Al MusterApril 27, 2012 13:17 EST

Since it was brought up here - in actuality it was the Osel Mukpo who approached Penor Rinpoche stating that he was the reincarnation of Mipham the Great based on a note he claimed was from his father.

Penor Rinpoche, being innocent and feeling extremely sad that someone would approach him asking to be reconginized as tulku, agreed to recognize his claim.

Penor Rinpoche did infact attempt to educate Osel Mukpo, however, once he recieved his title he felt there was no need to actually recieve any education.

Note that to date, no tibetian rinpoches have recieved any teachings from Osel, nor do they truely recognize him as a real teacher. Additionally, Penor Rinpoche's successor does not recognize Osel Mukpo as a tulku reincarnation of Mipham rinpoche, nor Dispite Osel's political attempts to get his next born recognized as the lineage holder of Penor Rinpoche, those attempts will not be successful.

have any claim on Penor Rinpoche's reincarnation

Add a comment

  
I agree to walrusmagazine.com’s comments policy.

Canada & its place in the world. Published by
the non-profit charitable Walrus Foundation
TwitterFacebookRSS
On newsstands now
New Issue on Sale
June 2012
Subscribe online for as little as $2.49 an issue. Visit The Walrus Store
to buy prints of our covers
The Walrus Foundation National Event Guide

The Walrus HOOPP Pension Debate
Be It Resolved That Canadians Are Incapable
of Saving for Their Retirement Needs Alone

12 pm, Wednesday, May 30 at
Hart House Debate Room, Toronto

The Walrus Glenbow Debate
Calgary’s Cowboy Culture:
Living Legacy or Just History?

6:30 pm, Thursday, June 7 at
Epcor Centre: Max Bell Theatre, Calgary

The Walrus Laughs
The Walrus SoapBox